
Big Insurance said they were struggling. The numbers tell a different story.
For years, big insurance companies have told Louisiana families the same thing: the business climate here is “unfavorable.” They blamed consumers and the courts, claiming there were too many claims and too much litigation. And on that basis, insurers raised rates, restricted claims, and pushed to strip away consumers' legal rights.
Now the truth is coming out.
State Farm — the largest auto insurer in Louisiana, covering roughly 30% of the market — is paying out a $5 billion dividend nationwide. That includes $136 million back to Louisiana drivers, averaging about $138 per vehicle.
We are happy that some of that money is going back to consumers, but why are they paying out a dividend? Because their underwriting profits were stronger than expected.
In plain English, they collected WAY more in premiums than they needed to pay claims.
In 2025 alone, State Farm reported $1.5 billion in underwriting profit. But here's the kicker: underwriting or selling policies isn't even the main way insurers make money. They make most of their profits by investing the premiums you pay for insurance. And in 2025, State Farm made another $7 billion from investments and other income.
Struggling companies don't make $8.5 billion in profit in a single year — and they don't issue massive rebates.
The insurance industry is not being crushed by an “oppressive environment” in Louisiana. They are doing very well. Louisiana families are being crushed by unaffordable insurance rates. And we deserve better.
We deserve honesty. We deserve accountability. Louisiana families deserve rates based on facts — not fear.
It’s time to stop protecting insurance company profits and start protecting policyholders.










